How Early Should We Mix Pitches When Making Swing Changes?
How much uncertainty can we add while a hitter is still getting useful reps on a swing change?
Listen to article
AI narrationReady when you are.
A hitter is working with a short trainer against a machine set to throw the ball down in the zone. We’re looking for more forward torso bend during the load and stride phase and more side bend as they rotate toward impact. They start to find a feel for it and make solid contact on the low pitch. Then the machine spits one out at the top of the zone and they swing underneath it.
If we’re strictly working on moving a specific way, then no big deal. They expected a pitch to be in a certain location, committed to a specific swing, and executed. The ball just wasn’t where they were expecting it to be. We’ll try again on the next pitch. That’s where I start to wonder what we mean when we call this hitting practice. In that round, we’ve given the hitter a problem that’s a little more like a golf shot. The ball is moving, but they already know roughly where they’re trying to meet it. In a game, they have to figure that out while the pitch is on its way.
When I talk about hitting as a skill, I mean reading the pitch, deciding whether to swing, and if you do, getting the barrel to the ball on time. A drill can give the hitter practice with one part of that. Mixing two hittable locations brings back a specific part of the game. The hitter has to pick up where the pitch is headed and organize the swing for it. How early can we ask them to do that while they work on a swing change?
I’ve seen examples like this one enough times to wonder what would happen if we put that second pitch in the round on purpose. One whiff gives me very little to go on. I’d want to see what the hitter does with the next high pitch, and what happens when the ball goes back down. Can they cover the pitch up and then find the adjustment again without knowing the low pitch is coming?
I wrote about how a real mechanical change can show up in an assessment, or even in a game swing, while the hitter still struggles to hit. Here I’m interested in how soon we can ask for that adjustment during mechanical prep. The Gap Between Practice and Performance
The case for starting with a mix
We already use the bat, the pitch, and the ball flight we’re asking for to help the hitter find a change from the early rounds. I like what that work does. What I want to explore is whether we can keep that same focus and give the hitter a second pitch to solve while they’re still finding the feel.
If the hitter can already find the adjustment on a low pitch, even occasionally, I’m interested in mixing from the first round. I’d keep the short trainer and the speed the same, throw mostly hittable pitches down, and mix in a few high strikes without calling the location. The hitter still gets plenty of chances to work on the low pitch. They also get reps recognizing the high pitch, adjusting to it, and coming back to the adjustment when the ball goes down again. I’d expect them to move differently at the two heights.
Hall and colleagues found that college hitters who practiced the same three pitch types in mixed order improved more on batting transfer tests than hitters who practiced them in blocks. Czyż and colleagues found an overall transfer benefit for mixed practice, with weaker results in applied settings. A sport-specific review by Ammar and colleagues found no clear advantage. The baseball study gives me a reason to take pitch order seriously, but it compared schedules over six weeks. It leaves me with a practical question. How much uncertainty can I add while the hitter is still getting useful reps on the change?
- A
- A
- A
- B
- B
- B
- C
- C
- C
- A
- C
- B
- A
- B
When I’d give the hitter a few known pitches
Porter and Magill asked a question closer to the one I’m interested in. They compared blocked practice, random practice, and a schedule that began with blocked reps and gradually mixed tasks. The gradual schedule produced better delayed retention in novice golf putting and better retention and transfer in novice basketball passing. An experienced hitter changing part of a familiar swing is dealing with a different problem, especially when they have to respond to an incoming ball. Still, those results give me a reason to consider how the hitter enters the task.
Say we start with the mix and the hitter spends the whole round trying to catch up. They rarely get a low-pitch rep where they can explore what we’re working on. I might slow down both pitches so they have more time and still have to pick up the location. If they’re still searching for a feel, I’d give them a few known low pitches and bring the high pitch back. I’d make that decision based on what the hitter is getting out of the round. A few misses while they’re figuring out how to cover both pitches are different from a round where they rarely get a useful swing at either one.
What would make me change my mind?
I’d want to compare two openings. In one, both heights are in play from the first round. In the other, the hitter gets a short run of known low pitches before the high pitch comes in. I’d keep the bat, speed, coaching focus, and total number of pitches at each height the same across the two approaches. Then I’d see how the hitter handles the same unannounced mix with their game bat, ideally again at the next session before I remind them what we worked on.
If the hitter consistently covers both heights better after starting with a short block, I’d give that block more room. If they start with a mix, make solid contact on the low pitch just as often later, and cover the high pitch better, I’d have a reason to keep the mix early even if the first round looked rougher. That would tell me something about how to run prep. I’d still want to see whether it helps against a pitcher, when the hitter has to account for different speeds and shapes and decide whether to swing.
I’m inclined to try a small mix early because I want the hitter to spend some of their prep time finding the adjustment in response to the pitch. What I want to learn is how much predictable practice each hitter needs before that becomes productive.
Research references
- Hall, K. G., Domingues, D. A., & Cavazos, R. (1994). Contextual interference effects with skilled baseball players. Perceptual and Motor Skills, 78(3), 835–841. https://doi.org/10.1177/003151259407800331
- Czyż, S. H., Wójcik, M., & Solarská, P. (2024). The effect of contextual interference on transfer in motor learning: A systematic review and meta-analysis. Frontiers in Psychology, 15, 1377122. https://doi.org/10.3389/fpsyg.2024.1377122
- Ammar, A., Trabelsi, K., Boujelbane, M. A., Boukhris, O., Glenn, J. M., Chtourou, H., & Schöllhorn, W. I. (2023). The myth of contextual interference learning benefit in sports practice: A systematic review and meta-analysis. Educational Research Review, 39, 100537. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.edurev.2023.100537
- Porter, J. M., & Magill, R. A. (2010). Systematically increasing contextual interference is beneficial for learning sport skills. Journal of Sports Sciences, 28(12), 1277–1285. https://doi.org/10.1080/02640414.2010.502946